Richmond & Twickenham RSS Feed


21-year-old Clare Watson reveals daily battle to board London's buses


A wheelchair-bound 21-year-old today lifts the lid on the nightmare she faces every time she tries to use public transport.

Clare Watson is humiliated on a daily basis by being denied access to buses by drivers who refuse to lower their ramps to allow her on board.

She said: “I’m too scared to go out on my own now. There’s a problem with bus drivers refusing to let me on or just driving past when they see me. I have made five complaints in less than a week as they have refused to put their ramps down.

“It’s a horrible feeling when that happens – you feel worthless and everybody stares. It’s humiliating.

“I don’t want to do it anymore as they drive off, so now mum has to come with me.”

Miss Watson, who has a neurological condition that left her wheelchair-bound four years ago, is dependant on public transport. Although buses are said to be wheelchair-friendly she has found her experience of travelling around the capital anything but.

Transport for London has launched an investigation.

Among the reasons she is given by drivers are: There are buggies in the wheelchair space – but these are meant to be folded up if a disabled person wishes to board; The ramp is not working – although policy is to check them before buses leave the depot; Or they drive past without stopping at all.

And the problems are not just restricted to one bus, there are four main routes that Miss Watson and her mother Santina, 45, of Portman Avenue, East Sheen, use regularly and the pair say they have encountered problems on all of them.

Mrs Watson said: “The 33, 337, 493 and 65 are our main buses and it has happened on every single one of these buses – it happens on a daily basis. We have been standing waiting for the doors to open and they have just driven off. Very often members of the public have to intervene.

“We told Transport for London (TfL) and they were great, very supportive, very considerate and very apologetic – they don’t want this from their drivers either.”

She added: “In the beginning Clare had a really good positive attitude about getting about, but her confidence has just been shattered because of the amount of times she has had problems.”

London United, which operates three of the bus routes close to Miss Watson’s home, said it was investigating the matter.

A spokesman said: “London United takes complaints of this nature very seriously. We are conducting a full investigation into the incidents raised by the passenger and will take appropriate action once all of the information is available.”

Arriva, which operates the fourth route, said drivers received regular training and the company was confident it was providing the service it was supposed to.

Colin Atkins, managing director of Arriva London, said: “The buses are there to offer a service and a lot of investment has taken place to offer an inclusive service.”

London Travel Watch, the transport watchdog, said bus drivers failing to pick up disabled passengers was a problem. A spokesman said: “It is something that concerns us. We know it happens and it happens too much. Where it does happen people must try and report it to TfL.”

A TfL spokesman said it took the issue of accessibility very seriously. He said: “Wheelchair ramps are not an optional extra on London’s buses – they must be working before a bus leaves its garage. We expect all London bus drivers to be helpful and polite to customers at all times.

“We will therefore work with the bus operator to carry out a thorough investigation into this incident.”

• What do you think? Let us know by email (gholt@london.newsquest.co.uk), phone the newsdesk on 020 8744 4271 or leave a comment below.


Your Say YourLondon

EdwinaWaugh, Richmond says...
2:32pm Fri 30 Jul 10

This is a real disgrace, and whilst the bus company expresses concern, nothing is ever done. Another nightmare is to travel on the 209 bus. One or two drivers are gentlemen, but the others sit in the bus station at Hammersmith with the doors closed, and at the last moment open them for passengers to get in the bus, then shoot off before everyone is seated. I have seen elderly people thrown, but the driveso couldn't care less. Also, buggies are a **** nuisance. Most of the children in them are too old to need them, but their mothers find it easier to use buggies. If they had to fold them (as was was the case years ago) I don't think so many would use them. No wonder with lack of exercise ao many are fat. And of course, while mum is on the mobile, the children are gorging on junk food. Travel on buses is a nightmare for those of us blessed with mobility, so for those not so fortunate it must add to their problems.

Phillip Taylor, Phillip Taylor says...
8:39pm Fri 30 Jul 10

I agree with Edwina Waugh about this matter and she places a good perspective on travelling issues for older and disabled people.

I saw the problems which Mrs Watson had the other day because I use all the bus routes she does and was on one when an altercation occurred about the ramp and alleged buggy blocking. The driver was rude and did not want to know- this was not an isolated incident either.

I would not want to prejudice any current investigation but it is right to say that the vast majority of bus drivers are ok but there are always a few who are wholly miserable and will not assist.

With further massive rises in fares and cuts to the services, our bus services will need to be reviewed across London before the Olympics. The drivers should be given more training on how to be customer-friendly because some clearly do not have the requisite skills at the present time to do the job properly.

We, as the travelling customers have no rights effectively when we use public transport.... merely obligations.... to pay... but there must be more of a "two way street" on this (if I can use the phrase) so we don't feel harrassed.

I would like to think that something will be done about this before July 2012 but I doubt it very much unless there is better leadership and 'people skills' training within the bus service as a matter of urgency.

Phillip Taylor

sweetdelilah, says...
2:17pm Sun 1 Aug 10

I agree that many bus drivers fly round these routes like they are on a bonus for finishing early. But seriously in this day and age how are we in a situation where there are only enough spaces on a bus for a wheelchair user or a parent with a child in a buggy?

It is not as easy as it might seem to lift a sleepy 2 year old from a buggy and fold it when it feels like the bus is on a formular 1 track! But this really shouldn't be a choice we have to make, there should be allocated room for us all!

martnal, Teddington says...
9:16am Mon 2 Aug 10

I think there are two problems with buses, which I do actually use often. Drivers are too heavily supervised to ensure that they run strictly on time. This means that they do not put passengers first. The other problem is that management do nothing to control anti-social behaviour in its many forms. The drivers turn a blind eye to it, as they are afraid of assualts, so anything untoward happening in the bus gets ignored. I've never seen a bus driver treat a disabled passenger badly, but if this story is true, then management need to reassess their priorities.

lucullus, says...
11:36am Mon 2 Aug 10

Edwina is, of course right: our children - of all ages - should be walking everywhere barefoot, gnawing on potatoes for sustenance, and thanking their relevant god for the fact that they exist in the first place.

I want to believe you're not the fatuous idiot you sound like, but it's really hard to wonder if you've ever managed children under the age of 3. Then, perhaps you'd prefer all these mums hop into Chelsea tractors instead, to leave the bus for you and your ego.

EdwinaWaugh, Richmond says...
3:42pm Mon 2 Aug 10

Lucullus: What a pity it is that you have selected a great Roman nom de plume, yet haven't learned the art of rhetoric. Your phlebian roots reveal themselves in your spiteful personal attacks. Disagree with me by all means, but your ignorance and aggressive rantings are not pleasant, so I shall ignore any future comments you make.

Angela M, London says...
4:55pm Mon 2 Aug 10

I get annoyed when someone gets on with a giant buggy - especially when it's holding a fidgety, energetic child who is actually requesting to be let out! In some cases they leave the buggy set up in the wheelchair space, then the child lounges across a double seat and the mother uses another.

I'm guessing that there was a buggy on-board when the bus drove past this poor woman. Some bus drivers are just too scared of the abuse they will get for asking someone to move.

ILUVTDH, says...
5:56pm Mon 2 Aug 10

I think this is ridiculous that those buses are doing that. I take offense to it due to the fact that I'm disabled, but not in a wheelchair. However, I do have friends in wheelchairs. I think that the bus drivers need to start being more considerate of those of us who are disabled and have a harder challenge with transportation.

lucullus, says...
11:04am Wed 4 Aug 10

Edwina, I'll be missing your enlightened conversation, but I obviously completely accept you've won the argument by choosing to ignore me. Congratulations for besting my phlebian (sic) rhetoric!

QueenNutkin, richmond says...
2:53pm Wed 4 Aug 10

The buses need more space for folded buggys. On most there is only a small space near the front doors and these are only really suitable for bags, they should consider extending these spaces. I agree with Angela M about those leaving empty buggies and letting the children sit on the seats, it is ridiculous. I also think that those people who intend to travel on public transport with babies should maybe consider getting suitable smaller buggies that can be folded easily and not take up half the gangway so other travellers cannot get to seats easily.
There is a lot of problems with public transport and its users, a lot of them could be solved with a few manners and a little common courtesy from everyone.

Sanity99, Twickenham says...
11:12am Thu 5 Aug 10

I love petty bickering in forums. Phlebian actually means 'pertaining to phlebes. Phlebes are hollow tubes carrying various fluids. Usually veins.

lucullus, says...
2:09pm Thu 5 Aug 10

Well, if you *really* like perry bickering, you should get yourself off to this place: http://ifyoulikeitso
muchwhydontyougolive
there.com/

One day I will have been petty enough to be worthy of a mention!

EdwinaWaugh, Richmond says...
2:49pm Thu 5 Aug 10

Sanity99, Twickenham
Thanks for pointing out my careless spelling mistake for plebeian. I stand corrected.
Alas, all we ever have on these blogs are petty arguments. Personal attacks are the norm here, certainly no rhetoric. I am, however, pleased it gives you amusement, and I too have a good laugh. Once again, apologies for my disgraceful spelling.

Sanity99, Twickenham says...
3:21pm Thu 5 Aug 10

"perry bickering"?

Is that an argumentative drink made from pears?

Phillip Taylor, Phillip Taylor says...
4:02pm Thu 5 Aug 10

It is good to see that the "Richmond and Kingston Informer" now has an interactive website and they are running this story on that site in some detail.

This is the link

www.richmondinformer
.co.uk


Phillip Taylor

Comments are closed on this article.

Investigation: Clare Watson has made five complaints this week after drivers refused to lower the ramp Investigation: Clare Watson has made five complaints this week after drivers refused to lower the ramp

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »