German Shepherd starved to death in cage
11:42am Thursday 2nd August 2012 in News Exclusive By Jim Palmer
DISTRESSING PHOTOS - A DIFFICULT DECISION
After careful consideration News Shopper decided to publish these photos to help convey the immense suffering this poor creature endured.
It was not an easy decision but we hope that printing images such as these will encourage people to report any incidents of animal cruelty to the relevant authorities immediately.
We appreciate some people will find the images distressing and/or that the photographs should have been withheld from public view, but if this story helps protect just one animal from a similar fate in the future, it will have been worth while.
Call the RSPCA on 0300 1234 999
TRAPPED in a squalid cage all day every day, German Shepherd Jack starved to death inch-deep in his own excrement.
One of his owners, 25-year-old Paul James Brunsden was jailed for 20 weeks and banned from ever keeping an animal again at Dartford Magistrates’ Court on Wednesday (August 1).
Jack’s co-owner – Stacey Louise Lockhurst - was warned she faced a similar fate.
Judge Michael Kelly said it was “one of the worst cases of animal cruelty I have ever come across.”
He added: “This dog was effectively tortured and neglected.”
Brunsden, formerly of Neptune Terrace in Erith but now living in Hornchurch, and 27-year-old Lockhurst both pleaded guilty to two charges of causing unnecessary suffering to the black and tan dog.
One charge was for not addressing the fact the pet was underweight and another for keeping it in a small, squalid cage.
RSPCA inspectors visited Lockhurst’s home in Forest Road, Erith, in October 2010 when Jack was 16 weeks old.
They recommended a plastic box he was kept in was taken away and gave the pair – who jointly owned the dog – advice on training. t printing images such as thes
Noticing they were struggling, the inspectors suggested they hand over ownership.
Seven months later, they found Jack dead in the same crate, covered by a curtain.
Prosecutor Andrew Wiles said: “When the top of the crate was removed it was clear the dog was emaciated. There was an inch or more of faeces covering all of the floor except where the dog was laying.”
The container was teeming with flies and maggots and littered with plastic bags and a takeaway food carton. A water bowl was full of excrement, as was the dog’s mouth.
Mr Wiles said: “There was a strong smell of ammonia, faeces and decomposing flesh.”
Lifting Jack out of the pen, an RSCPA inspector said she could feel his spine from the underside of his body.
Mr Wiles said: “She described it as the thinnest dog she had ever seen.”
A post mortem examination showed Jack was emaciated, had no fat and likely died of starvation.
The examining vet concluded Jack “suffered greatly and unnecessarily for a great period of time”.
Defending Lockhurst, Robert DeBanzie said she suffered from “pronounced learning disabilities” and emotional problems and has since been rehoused in a respite centre in Erith where she had made “gigantic steps”.
Lockhurst was granted unconditional bail while probation reports are prepared. She will return for sentencing at Dartford Magistrates’ Court on September 7.
Judge Kelly said: “There is a real risk you will be serving a prison sentence for this.”
Defending Brunsden, Frederick Hookway argued his client had reduced culpability because he did not live at the house where the dog was kept, although he did stay there sometimes.
Sentencing Brunsden to 20 weeks in prison and disqualifying him for life from owning animals, Judge Kelly said: “This is one of the worst cases of animal cruelty I have come across.
“This dog was confined in a little cage so small it appears it could barely stand up.
“It was kept there without being allowed out at all for any exercise or freedom and was starved to death.
“You could have released the dog. You could have provided food for it. You were offered help and advice from the RSPCA.
“I can’t think that any human being would have failed to recognise the suffering and distress of this dog.”
Comments(83)
MFC Lion
says...
1:11pm Thu 2 Aug 12
Bevangirl
says...
2:11pm Thu 2 Aug 12
Halls123
says...
2:54pm Thu 2 Aug 12
I hate any form of abuse and neglect against anything that is unable to look after and care for itself. Be it an animal, child, the elderly or someone with significant learning difficulties.
What makes this case even worse was they were offered help from the RSPCA. Low life scum.
catspodge
says...
3:35pm Thu 2 Aug 12
Bevangirl
says...
6:24pm Thu 2 Aug 12
lindarose
says...
9:50pm Thu 2 Aug 12
i have moved into a small flat so i can no longer have a dog as i don,t think its right to have a dog in a small flat , I hope the scum that did this to that poor animal get what they deserve in prison if i had my way they would be locked in the same size as that poor dog . rot in jail you scum bags
ivetka
says...
6:22am Fri 3 Aug 12
Witchkid
says...
8:10am Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
3:05pm Fri 3 Aug 12
TougherPunishment
says...
3:13pm Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
3:41pm Fri 3 Aug 12
justjackuk
says...
4:59pm Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
5:29pm Fri 3 Aug 12
justjackuk
says...
6:18pm Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:I can read the anger in your words!! .. this truly is disgusting!!!
Definetally i will do that locked them in tiny cage where they wont be even able to move and let them starved to death this bastards. I wish this will really happened!! I keep thinking whole day about this poor puppy jack and i am very sad special it comes to my mind this poor inocent puppy was suffering for long seven months!! Hopefully there will be revange for this bastards and same in canada vancouver for that guy who tortured that poor german shepherd name captain. To bad nobody help this poor dogs. I hope somebody will look after this abusive bastards!!!
Bevangirl
says...
6:49pm Fri 3 Aug 12
Witchkid
says...
7:12pm Fri 3 Aug 12
Looking at this woman's Facebook page, it appears that she has a young child, so she can't really use her 'pronounced learning disabilities' and 'emotional problems' as a defence. If so, then the child should be taken into care for her own safety!
justjackuk
says...
7:15pm Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
7:31pm Fri 3 Aug 12
Witchkid
says...
7:37pm Fri 3 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
7:40pm Fri 3 Aug 12
justjackuk
says...
7:40pm Fri 3 Aug 12
com/stacey.lockhurst
ivetka
says...
10:22pm Fri 3 Aug 12
Inspirationalady28
says...
3:56pm Sat 4 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
9:52pm Sat 4 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
12:31am Sun 5 Aug 12
MrsRCullen
says...
12:53am Sun 5 Aug 12
MrsRCullen
says...
12:53am Sun 5 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
1:17am Sun 5 Aug 12
beanie59
says...
7:55am Sun 5 Aug 12
piglet2011
says...
3:27pm Sun 5 Aug 12
It is very easy to sit at a PC and moan and rant but the reality is the RSPCA is the only charity that puts the welfare of animals first and works around the clock fighting abuse and cruelty.
ivetka
says...
9:09pm Sun 5 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
9:23pm Sun 5 Aug 12
mollykins
says...
1:08pm Mon 6 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:18pm Mon 6 Aug 12
L-l-l-y may
says...
8:50pm Mon 6 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
9:44pm Mon 6 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
10:11pm Mon 6 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
10:34pm Mon 6 Aug 12
the wall
says...
10:42am Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:Sorry but what do you think this petition is going to do in a English court?
if somebody wants to sign petition for jack against this two bastards here is the site: CARE2PETITIONSITE under JUSTICE FOR JACK- please sign and share . They already collect 1862 signatures since aug 3 . More signatures will help to punished this two loosers killers!!!!
the wall
says...
11:40am Tue 7 Aug 12
piglet2011 wrote:Oh Really ! Looks like you have fallen for all RSPCAs propaganda. RSPCA is one of the largest charities in the UK, with 1,505 employees (as of 2008). In 2008, total income was £119,926,000, total expenditure was £114,090,000, and reserves were £70,656,000.
RSPCA is a charity with limited resources. It is very easy to sit at a PC and moan and rant but the reality is the RSPCA is the only charity that puts the welfare of animals first and works around the clock fighting abuse and cruelty.
Have a read of this story one of many which is sad:
http://www.telegraph
.co.uk/comment/colum
nists/christopherboo
ker/7920217/Did-the-
RSPCA-drive-a-man-to
-suicide.html
Maybe read some more injust work by the RSPCA :
http://www.rspcainju
stice.blogspot.co.uk
/
Emz111
says...
11:44am Tue 7 Aug 12
20 Weeks is to short of a time they should get alot longer than that. If a human they would of got life.
This is discusting!!!!!
the wall
says...
11:50am Tue 7 Aug 12
CHARITY PLAYING GOD AND VICTIMISING PENSIONERS, YET AGAIN!
A RETIRED woman finally reunited with her dog ten months after it was seized by the RSPCA has revealed how her life was turned upside down by the animal charity.
Spinster Georgina Langley, 67, lives at a cottage in West Hougham and, since her mother died, has lived with only her pets for company.
She earned a reputation in the village as the "cat lady" and people would leave strays and unwanted pets with her.
On June 22 last year three RSPCA inspectors with police reinforcement swooped on her home and took away her 13 cats, four cockerels and her dog, Sweetie, who she had taken in at the request of villagers.
"It was the start of the most frightening ten months of my life," Miss Langley said. "I've never been in trouble with the police and had never seen the inside of a courtroom."
Within days she was told the RSPCA had put down five of her cats. Frightened Miss Langley contacted her vet, David Smith, who demanded to see the bodies.
Mr Smith of Lakeview Veterinary Centre – which operates in Hawkinge, Finglesham and Deal – said he had been left shocked by the way Miss Langley had been raided and asked the Royal Veterinary College to carry out an independent post-mortem examination on a ginger Tom and an adult female – which was pregnant with three kittens.
He said: "There appears to be no good reason why the RSPCA allowed these animals to be put to sleep. The RVC post mortems concluded the cats were healthy with no signs of incorrect feeding or problems with fleas or other illnesses."
The vet said he believed Miss Langley had become overwhelmed by the responsibility in a house where poor building work had left her with water leaks and lack of lighting.
Mr Smith said: "The inside of her house may not have been in a condition that many people would choose to live, but the animals were happy. This lady needed help and support, not hauling through the courts."
Miss Langley's court ordeal began in August when she was told she would face 13 charges of neglect and failing to look after her animals properly.
She was given legal aid to fight her case and was represented by Nigel Weller, a solicitor from East Sussex who has built a reputation fighting RSPCA court cases.
After three preliminary hearings, Miss Langley faced a three-day trial in March, but the RSPCA dropped 11 of the 13 charges. Miss Langley pleaded guilty to failing to get veterinary care quickly enough for two of her animals.
The animal charity pushed for court costs of £28,000, asking magistrates to make an order on the pensioner's home, and called for her to be banned from keeping animals.
But on Friday, April 20, magistrates ordered that Miss Langley's dog, cockerels and one cat should be returned. She was given a conditional discharge with no fine or costs imposed.
"It was such a relief," said Miss Langley. "I agreed the surviving cats could be rehomed and I would keep just one. I cannot believe an organisation like the RSPCA could be so heavy-handed – I would never treat anyone the way they have treated me."
The RSPCA said it had no plans to review its use of vets following criticism the five cats should not have been destroyed and maintained that it works with people who find difficulty looking after their animals .
Spokeswoman Klare Kennett said: "We tried to help Miss Langley, but were turned away, so had no choice but to take the animals into our care."
She said the costs of £28,000 covered the charity's bill for bringing the case to court.
Miss Langley, who walks with a stick because she needs a new hip, now receives home visits twice a week through Social Services to help her cope at home.
http://www.thisisken
t.co.uk/Owner-s-orde
al-seized-pets/story
-16041918-detail/sto
ry.html
Bevangirl
says...
1:12pm Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:25pm Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:41pm Tue 7 Aug 12
the wall
says...
5:29pm Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:Tell me, do they still smash in baby seals heads in your country with a hakapik: (a heavy wooden club with a hammer head and metal hook on the end). Or just just shoot them in the head?
I dont know what this petition will do in english court and i know we wont bring this poor jack back but i signed this petition for inocent jack and wont hurt me to sign this. Maybe it wont help and maybe it will they collect 2419 signatures already since august 3. Worth it to try i guess. Hopefully this two Lockhurst and Brusden will pay for that what they did to this puppy.
ivetka
says...
6:21pm Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
6:24pm Tue 7 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
5:10pm Wed 8 Aug 12
Witchkid
says...
12:48pm Thu 9 Aug 12
.org/index.php
ivetka
says...
3:26pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:08pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:18pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:21pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:29pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
4:38pm Thu 9 Aug 12
the wall
says...
4:42pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:That petition has a target of 4000. This means nothing to the UK government and will not change anything.
I didnt start petition for this inocent dog jack i just signed this petition. I have two kids and dog plus cat and i am good person with big heart i never raised my hand on my kids or my pets then stop with your stupid comments.
ivetka
says...
5:05pm Thu 9 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
8:42pm Thu 9 Aug 12
L-l-l-y may
says...
10:36pm Thu 9 Aug 12
emelem
says...
12:27pm Fri 10 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
3:22pm Fri 10 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
10:05pm Fri 10 Aug 12
the wall
says...
10:30am Tue 14 Aug 12
Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?
emelem
says...
12:35pm Tue 14 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
3:47pm Tue 14 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
3:51pm Tue 14 Aug 12
the wall wrote:Dont check on petition site you dont belong there!
You still here?
Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?
ivetka
says...
4:06pm Tue 14 Aug 12
the wall wrote:Do yo know anything about nature??? Polar bears and whales are eating seals and this two **** tortured that inocent puppy jack! !!! I was reading few stories about more people tortured dogs or cats in uk. I hope you are not one of them! !
You still here?
Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?
the wall
says...
5:17pm Tue 14 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:You are very thick !
the wall wrote: You still here? Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?Do yo know anything about nature??? Polar bears and whales are eating seals and this two **** tortured that inocent puppy jack! !!! I was reading few stories about more people tortured dogs or cats in uk. I hope you are not one of them! !
Polar bears and whales are eating seals - That's natural, it's their food
.
In Canada baby seals are beaten to death for their fur. But you don't care about them.
Your English is poor so you have missed the point of what has been said. You don't understand English law but what to stick your nose in our affaires with some stupid online petition.
Every time you post on the NS web site we all laugh at you.
You're a crank!
That petition will change nothing.
the wall
says...
5:21pm Tue 14 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:What sort of reply is that? You make no sense.
the wall wrote: You still here? Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?Dont check on petition site you dont belong there!
Tell us all what this petition is for?
the wall
says...
5:30pm Tue 14 Aug 12
Do they hunt bears ? YES
Is Canada one of the biggest exporters of animal fur ? YES
The country you live in KILLS wild animals for money.
ivetka
says...
6:02pm Tue 14 Aug 12
the wall wrote:You better check your spelling in your previous comments! !!!Then i guess whole world is sticking nose into those two creeps action!! So far i can see people are very angry what those two creeps did to poor puppy!!
Do they still trap animals Canada ? YES
Do they hunt bears ? YES
Is Canada one of the biggest exporters of animal fur ? YES
The country you live in KILLS wild animals for money.
ivetka
says...
6:13pm Tue 14 Aug 12
the wall wrote:This petition is for to stop animal cruelty!!! To punished this two creeps!!! And tell me why there is to many people from uk who is signing this petition??? Because they are against this two creeps and against animal cruelty!!!
ivetka wrote:What sort of reply is that? You make no sense.
the wall wrote: You still here? Don't you care about the baby seals killed in your country ?Dont check on petition site you dont belong there!
Tell us all what this petition is for?
emelem
says...
6:16pm Tue 14 Aug 12
ivetka
says...
7:21pm Tue 14 Aug 12
emelem wrote:Do you think this is normal to put little puppy to crate and let him starved to death? How human can do something like that to inocent animal?? I do have dog and cat and i treat them very good they deserve love from human and not to be tortured.
well, i'm unchecking the option to get notifications when replies are made because now it's gone way off topic and resorted to insults. waste of my time to check them and even more of a waste of your time to make them. write to those who are in charge of putting in place these sentences, over and over again until the laws and the punishments change. at least do that for every animal that suffers or dies at the hands of humans.
ivetka
says...
9:34pm Tue 14 Aug 12
the wall
says...
9:53am Wed 15 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:This person was being nice and you attack them. They have said how go about getting things changed and you have a go at them.
emelem wrote: well, i'm unchecking the option to get notifications when replies are made because now it's gone way off topic and resorted to insults. waste of my time to check them and even more of a waste of your time to make them. write to those who are in charge of putting in place these sentences, over and over again until the laws and the punishments change. at least do that for every animal that suffers or dies at the hands of humans.Do you think this is normal to put little puppy to crate and let him starved to death? How human can do something like that to inocent animal?? I do have dog and cat and i treat them very good they deserve love from human and not to be tortured.
This is what I mean about you not understanding English. You are the one that is being rude.
Wind your neck in and do one.
ivetka
says...
4:49pm Wed 15 Aug 12
the wall wrote:I didnt attack this person at all . I only asked this person what he think about this situation ??? Because only you are the one who thinks this is not big deal what those two creeps did to puppy jack . I was not rude to this person !
ivetka wrote:This person was being nice and you attack them. They have said how go about getting things changed and you have a go at them. This is what I mean about you not understanding English. You are the one that is being rude. Wind your neck in and do one.emelem wrote: well, i'm unchecking the option to get notifications when replies are made because now it's gone way off topic and resorted to insults. waste of my time to check them and even more of a waste of your time to make them. write to those who are in charge of putting in place these sentences, over and over again until the laws and the punishments change. at least do that for every animal that suffers or dies at the hands of humans.Do you think this is normal to put little puppy to crate and let him starved to death? How human can do something like that to inocent animal?? I do have dog and cat and i treat them very good they deserve love from human and not to be tortured.
ivetka
says...
5:02pm Wed 15 Aug 12
the wall
says...
5:05pm Wed 15 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:This is what I mean, your use of broken English makes you sound rude.
I was not rude to "emelem " person and if he or she think i was then i am sorry . Only person who is rude up here is "the wall" You are the one who is making fun of my english .
You don't even understand on so many levels.
ivetka
says...
5:13pm Wed 15 Aug 12
the wall wrote:No point to talk to you about this !!
ivetka wrote: I was not rude to "emelem " person and if he or she think i was then i am sorry . Only person who is rude up here is "the wall" You are the one who is making fun of my english .This is what I mean, your use of broken English makes you sound rude. You don't even understand on so many levels.
the wall
says...
5:18pm Wed 15 Aug 12
ivetka wrote:No point in talking to you about this.
the wall wrote:No point to talk to you about this !!ivetka wrote: I was not rude to "emelem " person and if he or she think i was then i am sorry . Only person who is rude up here is "the wall" You are the one who is making fun of my english .This is what I mean, your use of broken English makes you sound rude. You don't even understand on so many levels.
See what I mean.

Citygirl83 says...
12:50pm Thu 2 Aug 12
Evil scum, I hope you someday suffer the same fate as this poor dog.