WALTHAM FOREST: Unions slam 20k library survey

Walthamstow Central Library. Campaigners fear the council plans to slash budgets to library services across the borough. Walthamstow Central Library. Campaigners fear the council plans to slash budgets to library services across the borough.

A £20,000 survey will be used to justify drastic cuts to Waltham Forest’s library service, a union has warned.

Company BMG were paid to gauge residents’ views on libraries across the borough, work which UNISON claims is usually carried out by library staff.

But Waltham Forest Council denied this and defended the move, saying the ‘independent’ research will help minimise the effects of an unprecedented reduction in government funding.

However, Dave Knight, of UNISON Waltham Forest, believes questions in the survey are loaded in order to justify cuts.

He said: "We believe this survey was not impartial and that questions on the survey are biased in order to achieve a pre-ordained outcome.

Mr Knight added that he fears the council could come down hard on union members who criticise the decision to hire a private company to carry out the research.

But Cllr Geraldine Reardon, cabinet member for the arts, said: "As we are doing with every single service we provide, we are currently looking at how we can make every penny we spend on our libraries count.

“The purpose of the survey is to look at all aspects of our library service in an independent and objective manner and find ways of doing things in a more efficient and cost effective way.

"The findings of the survey will influence the development plan for the library service.

"We know that our libraries are highly valued by our residents and provide a wealth of learning and leisure facilities, and, as such, any decisions about our libraries will not be taken lightly."

UNISON has said it will organise some public meetings at libraries to challenge any possible cuts to the service.

Click here to follow the Waltham Forest Guardian on Twitter

Comments(9)

mdj says...
1:56pm Sun 19 Dec 10

It's perhaps time to remind readers that the Borough's libraries manager has no professional qualifications for the task, but was promoted four grades without outside competition to manage both libraries and museums, having presided over the sacking of the Keeper of the William Morris Gallery, the Borough's only employee with a world-wide reputation.
Not long after, in the wake of the apparent wanton destruction of over 200,000 books, and the botched refurbishment of the central library,which leaked for months causing huge damage after the builders had just left, a consultant from Haringey was paid nearly £60,000 to select new books - that's not to buy them, just to choose them!
This information was elicited at a Community Council, which goes to help explain why LBWF has abolished them.
I would have thought that this Borough had enough in-house expertise when it comes to destroying a library service, without paying outsiders to do the dirty work.

Redfox says...
8:58pm Sun 19 Dec 10

With such an arrogant management in council why doesn't Dave Knight initiate a Unison strike ballot and grind the whole badly shambles to a halt?
Bob Crow seems to take similar steps on the mearest pretext of passenger safety, so why can't Unison - for once, stand up and be counted with the residents.

Tom Thumb says...
10:12am Mon 20 Dec 10

The council has been wanting to shut down Wood Street library for years. I expect this impartial survey of public opinion will show that local people are eager to see it shut and handed over to a property developer, who will knock it down and build a 20 storey tower block on the site.
Redfox is right. But somebody should also be organising a mass protest of residents outside the town hall if the council tries to push more library closures through.

Sam Hain says...
3:09pm Mon 20 Dec 10

What would Nancy Taaffe know about neutrality? Answers on the back of a postage stamp please!

Dave Hall says...
10:53pm Mon 20 Dec 10

Why exactly should Nancy be neutral? She is a union organizer and is meant to be partial, on the side of the union members. This council is hostile to the whole concept of skilled experienced librarians, and the staff working in the libraries need defending from the council. Presumably the council have learned that closing down a library without any form of survey, as they did with the St James Street library, is bad PR. A survey carefully engineered to get a desired result is not any better.
And another thing... On the back of what sort of postage stamp? A republican one without the Queen's head as seems to be mooted by the ConDem friends of Sam?

Walthamster says...
11:54pm Mon 20 Dec 10

As Dave Hll says, Sam, why wouldn't Nancy Taaffe speaks up for the people she is supposed to represent?

I just wish she'd teach our councillors how to do the same. It would be a good start if they bothered to listen and reply to the people who elected them. They're quick enough to pocket their salary-sized allowances.

£20,000 on a pointless consultation is yet another waste of money, while they blame every cut on the government.

John_Morrison says...
5:28pm Wed 22 Dec 10

£20,000? Value for money old chaps

Zoreli says...
10:29am Thu 23 Dec 10

How many new books and CDs could they have bought with £20k?

As a frequent library user I'm really worried about the impact of any cuts on my local library (Leytonstone). Is there anything that we residents can do to prevent cuts, rather than reacting to an announcement after the decisions have been made?

Walthamster says...
11:29am Thu 23 Dec 10

I'd strongly advise you to take action now, Zoreli. St James Street Library Campaign was always at a disadvantage because it started after the library was closed without warning.
Also, two of their local councillors at the time were Liaquat Ali and Johar Khan, who did nothing to help.
Don't let your local councillors ignore you. If they don't turn up at their surgeries, tell the leader of their party and to the WF Guardian and insist on an answer from the councillors themselves.
Be polite but insistent. Get support from as many people as possible in the area.
Very important: get commitments from your councillors, IN WRITING, that they will write to you personally, and let the newspaper know, and put up notices in the that the library to warn if it is going to be closed.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree