Care home company ordered to pay £133,000 after woman with dementia was crushed to death by wardrobe

Care home company ordered to pay £133,000 after woman with dementia was crushed to death by wardrobe

Care home company ordered to pay £133,000 after woman with dementia was crushed to death by wardrobe

First published in News by

A care home company was ordered to pay £133,000 today after a woman with dementia was crushed to death when a wardrobe fell on her.

Claire Hughes, 64, was found underneath the wardrobe which had not been properly fixed to the wall at the Chase Care Centre in Printers Avenue, Watford.

The wardrobe had been locked because Mrs Hughes had become "obsessed" with clothing and would put on layer after layer when she was left alone, St Albans crown court heard.

But the wardrobe, which was on castors, had only been secured to plasterboard and not to the concrete wall. Screws at the top only went into chipboard and were not anchored.

On December 15, 2011, Edgware-born Mrs Hughes pulled down the wardrobe, which weighed 50 kilos and contained clothes weighing 11 kilos, on top of her. She had tugged off one of the doors, which had come away from its hinges. The cause of death was compression, said prosecutor Mark Watson.

Mrs Hughes had first met her husband Christopher when they were teenagers. They met again 40 years later and she married the retired company director in 2007 but she was then diagnosed with dementia. He had provided the chain and lock to prevent her opening the cupboard when she was alone. He attended the home to feed his wife who would not take food from anyone but him.

The company, which operates 37 homes and has its headquarters in Borehamwood, pleaded guilty to failing to discharge its duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. 

Dominic Kay, defending, said: "It is a very, very sad case. Mrs Hughes was well-liked by the staff. The company expresses its regret and remorse to her family.

"It was not foreseen that she would use the force she did on the wardrobe. It is not a case of corner cutting. It was an oversight."

He said the company had operated for 25 years without any convictions or warnings from the Health and Safety Executive. All the home's wardrobes are now secured with longer screws and a timber baton that are fixed into the concrete wall.

Judge John Plumstead said he acknowledged that Mrs Hughes had been well-cared for at the home. But he said: "This unfortunate lady was intent on gaining access to her clothing. Steps should have been taken to ensure the wardrobe was fixed. The attempt to fix the wardrobe was botched. The wardrobe was very poorly secured indeed. The company failed in their duty to keep this lady safe."

He fined the company £85,000 and ordered it to pay £48,000 costs.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:21am Fri 29 Aug 14

drunkenduck says...

Sad news esp as the woman had dementia and like so many gets treated unfairly, poorly and so many cases abused.

But in this case nobody used common sense about the wardrobe.
Sad news esp as the woman had dementia and like so many gets treated unfairly, poorly and so many cases abused. But in this case nobody used common sense about the wardrobe. drunkenduck
  • Score: 5

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree