Petersham cows not moo-ving back in, as fence proves divisive

Milking it: One councillor said the trust was using the fence row to remove the cows Milking it: One councillor said the trust was using the fence row to remove the cows

Cows will not return to Petersham Meadows later this year, despite the National Trust being paid more than £500,000 to keep them there.

The move comes after a long battle between the National Trust, Richmond Council, dog walkers and farmer Ian Brown, who looks after the cows that graze on the meadow.

The National Trust was paid a £500,000 endowment to keep the cows on the meadows but, following a dog attack on a cow in May 2011, the National Trust put a fence that proved unpopular.

Dogs are currently banned from the meadows but are allowed on leads on the paths.

Geri Silverstone, of the National Trust, said: “Unless we can come up with some sort of erection on the meadow we are not going to be able to break the status quo.

“Until we can get a decision on this it is not safe for us to put the cows on the meadow.”

The National Trust said it was disappointed the council rejected proposals to put a fence along the side of the meadow.

But ward councillor for Petersham Sir David Williams said the fence proposed by the National Trust would breach the 1902 Act, which protects the view from Richmond Hill - the only view in England to be protected by an act of Parliament.

He said: “The National Trust was making unreasonable demands and is using that as an excuse not to put the cattle back.

“For a national charity that is supposed to be looking after English heritage, it acts like a nasty property company that puts out PR spin if it doesn’t get its way.”

Last year, Richmond Council put forward a dog control order banning them from the meadow between April and November, which it was hoped would solve the problem.

The Regulatory Committee, which will decide if there should be a dog control order on the meadows, will take place next week on February 13.

Comments(5)

reesmf says...
11:56am Fri 8 Feb 13

My sympathies are firmly with the National Trust here. Dogs are a real problem and a dog control order is not going to help in the slightest. We need a barrier. The claim that this would break the protected view is such utter nonsense that it is unworthy of a reply.

Twickenham Bob says...
5:18pm Sat 9 Feb 13

The National Trust do a great deal of good work across the country - and their desire to find a permanent solution to protect the cows should be welcomed.

Ham House, a little further up the river is a wonderful treasure and its good to see that they are opening the House up for guided tours in the winter. Its well worth a visit.

It takes a lot of hard work & dedication to keep a place like Ham House going, and needs the support of local people to keep going.

germaninham says...
10:31pm Tue 12 Feb 13

It is a joke - thinking of cancelling my NT membership. There is no fence needed. Just ban dogs from the meadows during summer - simple. It would be very sad to loose the cows. The electric fence last year was bad enough.

Twickenham Bob says...
1:39am Wed 13 Feb 13

The National Trust consulted with the Health & Safety Executive who have rightly taken into account the number of recent cases nationally where the dog walker has been trampled to death by cows.

Most people from the countryside know that cows and dogs don't mix.

Just banning dogs wont solve the issue as the uninformed and stupid will still walk there dogs regardless and put the other unconnected walkers lives at risk.

You often see people at Bushy Park seeing how close they can get to a stag, with people even trying to get there children to 'pet' the stags around the duck pond

RiverLover says...
5:47am Wed 13 Feb 13

As far as I know no one has ever been trampled by a cow on the Petersham Meadows. The only incident that we know of is when a dog attacked a cow. The NT have overreacted and are taking away our heritage. They also are not fulfilling their agreement.

Twickenham Bob...so next up you will be happy to see the deer go?

Health and safety gone mad!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree