Fears West Middlesex Hospital could lose more than 100 beds
8:00am Saturday 27th October 2012 in News By Amy Dyduch
Concern: Bed losses were left out of the consultation
West Middlesex Hospital could lose more than a third of its beds if proposals from NHS North West London are brought in.
A recent survey from NHS North West London, entitled Shaping a Healthier Future, proposes the closure of four accident and emergency units – in Ealing, Charing Cross, Hammersmith and Central Middlesex Hospitals, and a large scale diversion of patients away from hospital inpatient and outpatient treatment.
But proposals to axe almost 1,000 hospital beds across north-west London by 2015 – including the loss of 119 beds from West Middlesex Hospital – were not included in the consultation.
This recent discovery has brought forward fresh doubts from public health experts over the viability and impact on patients from the controversial plans.
AWest Middlesex Hospital spokeswoman said: “The NHS North West London proposals anticipate changes in the way healthcare is provided which mean patients will be cared for and supported at home.
“When they go into hospital, their stay will be shorter than is currently the case.
“We will continue to plan and adjust our number of beds according to anticipated demand.”
London Health Emergency director Dr John Lister said West Middlesex’s attitude was “incredibly bizarre”.
He said: “I’m not at all reassured by that. Do we know how these people are going to be looked after outside of hospital?”
Referring the NHS North West London’s plans, he said: “This is a shockingly irresponsible plan, which is effectively being smuggled through without proper public debate. We have now heard the grave concerns of public health professionals – the very people whose job it is to take care of the health of whole populations – who fear that the system just will not be able to cope.
“We urge local health oversight and scrutiny committees, clinical commissioning groups and the primary care trusts to step in and force a re-opening of consultation and a proper debate with all the facts on the table for people to see.”
Comments(5)
Culverin
says...
3:46pm Sat 27 Oct 12
The Liberal Democrats promised us that councillors would be part of the CCGs but that's seems to be just another one of their promises.
As far as I know, the main CCG constituents are consultants from McKinsey and Price Waterhouse looking to save money.
It really doesn't look good, it's worse than Thatcher's dark days with the NHS. The dreadful coalition don't give a **** they're destroying everything important and they don't even have a mandate.
Scott Naylor
says...
3:04pm Sun 28 Oct 12
Besides which although it may be ok but hospital food hardly compares with home does it?
Isn't cataract removal a day procedure too, my mother had it done recently and she was in just for the day, as others I know are - so that again is not about using general wards, but making it as convenient as possible and having after-care at home, this is specially provided for all as needed. Not sure if this is a political posture or based on facts, just asking the question, open to correction....of course we can always pour more and more into the bottomless pit of health services, the question is how to deliver quality care and be responsible with money, we have all heard of the burgeoning non-clinical head count that grew out of proportion to the outcomes during past Government's tenancy. Now doesn't health care change over time, better techniques, better results, advances in medical and surgical science, always the cry of 'we cannot change that just because it has always been that way'? Anyhow the NHS coming together with the Council bringing together our services is a very welcome use of combining thinking heads and resource and has just happened here in our Borough.
aspicer
says...
4:55pm Mon 29 Oct 12
We can't afford the staff pensions, let alone the beds!!
Twickenham Bob
says...
9:19am Tue 30 Oct 12
The truth if the matter is that the NHS is being cut back as the population is growing and acing so only raising funding by consumer prices (not medical prices!) means less money per capita being spent.
Eye ops are a good example - of the new era of Tory NHS Rationing & Tory Postcode Lottery. The level of vision loss now has to be higher before patients can get treatment and oh - in most areas they will only mend one (refusing to operate on a second eye later on).
Lack of beds is also a real problem - I know of one person recently who was having a heart problem - but they had to turn the ambulance away as they had no doctors with enough experience to treat the patient as it was a weekend - lack of beds means lack of flexibility (extremely important for a hospital with and an emergency department) and a lack of depth in the clinical experience and expertise. The heart patient had to to bumped off to Hammersmith Hospital (Ealing).
Take knee operations - if West Mid only only did day surgery on knees it loses the ability to do emergency and trauma work on knees such as when a patient presents with say a knee infection. At the moment they tend to bump the case up to Charring Cross (Hammersmith).
Yes some day surgery can be done but that requires the patient to have someone able to look after them. If you are middle class and well off that's OK, but many people have taken Norman Tebbits bike to find work and don't live near home, or their children have moved away due to high house prices.
I personally know a number I doctors at West Middlesex and they all state it's bursting a the seams and relies on staff working overtime and well over the call of duty to stop the whole thing unravelling.
The lack of beds at West Middlesex means that at the present time is not really a full acute hospital - as it can't deal with many cases itself with inpatients being shipped to other hospitals for tests and the shipped back (cardio is particularly bad for that at West Mid) - and stripping out more will result in it becoming a minor non-acute hospital and the likely closure of the accident and emergency department.

Twickenham Bob says...
2:47pm Sat 27 Oct 12
It's delusional to think there needs to be less beds when the population is increasing rapidly in London and life expectancy is also increasing at a similarly fast rate.
The only way they will be able to do it is by denying people care they ought to be receiving - like cataract surgery - thereby significantly reducing the quality of care.
Within the local NHS bodies there is a democratic deficit where no one really knows what they are up to nor know what treatments and drugs are being denied.
When I visited hospitals in Germany everything is done so much better and really shows how healthcare is cruely rationed in the UK.